Why is it so hard for me to make decisions?
Answered by Giovanni Ceroni, engineer and NLP coach in Cesena, Italy, author of Strategic NLP – The Invisible Blade. The topic continues in the Premium Edition: Volume I, “Our Brain”, sections “Heuristics” and “Cognitive Biases”.
“I'm forever indecisive.” How many times have you said this sentence, or heard it said? What if it were not a matter of character, but of the way you are trying to decide? Many of our decisions are influenced by automatic processes: mental shortcuts, cognitive biases and criteria we use without being fully aware of them. The difficulty comes when these automatisms pull us in different directions, or when an important choice needs more attention than we are giving it. Recognising how we decide can help us choose better.
The shortcuts that decide for you
Heuristics are mental strategies, rules or shortcuts we use to make decisions quickly and to deal with complex situations without having to analyse every piece of available information.
They let us save time and energy. And in most everyday decisions, that is an advantage.
But a shortcut that works well in one situation could take us off course in another.
Cognitive biases are systematic distortions of judgement.
In the model I propose, while the heuristic simplifies the decision-making process, the bias can lead us to interpret information in a distorted way.
Let's look at three examples.
- Confirmation bias: we tend to look for, interpret and remember mostly the information that confirms what we already believe. If you are convinced that a colleague is unreliable, you may immediately notice one of his delays and overlook the many occasions on which he kept his commitments.
- Anchoring effect: the first piece of information we receive can influence our later evaluations. If a salesperson first quotes you a price of 10,000 euros and then lowers it to 7,000, you may perceive the second figure as particularly good value. But compared to what real value?
- Availability bias: we tend to judge as more probable or frequent whatever we can easily remember. After hearing the news of a particularly serious accident, you may overestimate the probability that a similar event will happen on your own trip. The vividness of a memory is not the same as the real frequency of an event.
Mental shortcuts are not enemies. The problem arises when we use them automatically, without noticing that they may not be appropriate to the situation.
Recognising them does not mean becoming immune to them.
It means gaining the possibility to stop, check the information and consider alternatives that until then we had not taken into account.
It is the space that separates the automatic reaction from the conscious choice.
The invisible criteria: metaprograms
Besides mental shortcuts, in NLP we observe metaprograms.
They are models that describe the habitual criteria through which we select information, evaluate experiences and steer our decisions.
They do not mean that a person is necessarily made a certain way. They help us recognise which criterion is being used in a given situation.
Three distinctions are particularly useful.
- Internal or external reference: some people tend to evaluate their decisions mainly by referring to their own criteria, others look for confirmation and evaluation from outside. A useful question is: “How do you know you did a good job?” Someone who mainly uses an internal reference might answer: “I know because I achieved the goals I had set myself.” Someone who uses an external reference might say: “I know because the client is satisfied.” Neither criterion is better in absolute terms. Their usefulness depends on the situation.
- General or detail: some people prefer to start from the overall vision, others need specific information before deciding. Imagine evaluating a new project. You might want to know the general objective first, or you might need to examine costs, timing and operating procedures. The question is: “To make this decision, what level of information do I need?”
- Towards or away from: some people steer their decisions mainly towards a desired result, others are motivated above all by the need to move away from an unwanted situation. “I want to change jobs to grow professionally.” “I want to change jobs because I can't stand this situation any more.” The desired behaviour is apparently the same. What motivates it changes.
Metaprograms are not meant to classify people.
The same person can use different criteria depending on the context, the goal and the information available.
Recognising the criterion you are using lets you check whether it is the most useful one for the decision you have to make.
Maybe you need an outside opinion. Maybe a detail you have not yet considered. Or a direction clear enough to begin to act.
When to slow down
Not all decisions deserve the same amount of attention.
If you have to choose what to eat for lunch, analysing every alternative could take more time than the result justifies.
But if you are deciding whether to accept an important assignment, change jobs or commit a considerable sum, relying only on your first impression may not be enough.
The useful question is not: “Am I using a mental shortcut?”
It is: “Does this decision deserve that I slow down and check how I am getting there?”
When the answer is yes, try to tell apart the result you have reached from the process that brought you to that conclusion.
What is convincing you?
The quality of the information?
The number of confirmations?
The first figure you heard?
Or the fact that a recent experience has stayed with you in a particularly vivid way?
It does not mean your decision is wrong.
It means checking whether the reasons that support it are sufficient.
An exercise
Think of a decision you are putting off.
Do not look for an answer right away. Take a few minutes to observe which information and which criteria you are using.
Then ask yourself these four questions.
- “What, exactly, is convincing me?” Identify the facts, the information and the evaluations on which you are building your conclusion.
- “Am I looking for contrary evidence with the same attention with which I look for confirmation?” Try to consider at least one piece of information that could challenge the choice you are leaning towards.
- “If I had not received that first piece of information, what would my assessment be?” It may be a price, a judgement or a forecast. Ask yourself how much that first piece of information is influencing your point of reference.
- “Why is this decision important to me?” Are you trying to reach a desired result, or to move away from a situation you no longer want? Observe which motivation prevails, without judging it. Then add a practical question: “What am I missing in order to decide?” You may find that you do not need more reflection, but a precise piece of information, a conversation, or a deadline by which to choose.
The most common mistakes
- Treating mental shortcuts as enemies. Heuristics let us deal quickly with many everyday situations. The goal is not to eliminate them, but to recognise when a choice calls for deeper analysis.
- Believing that knowing the name of a bias makes you immune to its effects. Being able to describe a mechanism does not necessarily mean recognising it while it is influencing a decision. It takes observation, checking and practice.
- Using biases to label other people's decisions. It is easy to spot a distortion in other people's choices. More interesting is to ask whether we are using the same mechanism in our own.
Where to start
The next time you face an important choice, try not to ask yourself only: “What is the right decision?”
Ask yourself also: “How am I arriving at this decision?”
You may notice that you are giving too much value to the first piece of information you received, that you are looking only for confirmation, or that you need a more precise criterion to evaluate the alternatives.
At that point, identify the missing information, decide how to obtain it, and choose when to make the decision.
To explore these mechanisms further, you can start with heuristics, continue with cognitive biases and arrive at metaprograms.
Because a decision does not become better only when the result changes.
It can become better the moment you learn to recognise the process through which you are making it.
The complete method
In the Premium Edition of Strategic NLP – The Invisible Blade you will find the practical map of heuristics and biases, and the metaprograms with their combinations, with examples and guidance to train yourself to recognise them.
Discover the Premium Edition