How to stop ruminating?
Answered by Giovanni Ceroni, engineer and NLP coach in Cesena, Italy, author of Strategic NLP – The Invisible Blade. The topic continues in the Premium Edition: Volume II, “Intervening on Structure”, section “Mental Focus”.
How to stop ruminating? First of all, I would distinguish reflecting from going back over the same thing without reaching a conclusion. Our brain selects information also according to what we focus our attention on. When the focus stays on what we fear, we risk continuing to find confirmation of our worries. What if, instead of looking for more answers to the same questions, we started asking different ones?
Why do we ruminate?
Focus is the point on which you concentrate your mental attention at a given moment. It can directly influence your mood: the mind works a bit like a projector, a spotlight that lights up what it concentrates on and amplifies its meaning.
When you keep turning your attention to the same worry, you risk leaving in the background other information that could help you interpret the situation differently.
You do not only see the reality in front of you. You also see the one you are looking for.
If you concentrate your attention exclusively on what is not working, the positive aspects can lose importance, even though they continue to exist.
So you risk confirming what you already think, strengthening what you confirm and building a circle in which your interpretation becomes more and more convincing.
Confirmation bias can also contribute to this process: we tend to favor information consistent with our beliefs, overlooking what might challenge them.
A thirty-second test
Let's do a small experiment.
Look at the room you are in and, for fifteen seconds, try to memorize all the yellow objects.
Done?
Now close your eyes, if you can do so safely.
Without looking again, try to remember how many blue objects there were.
You probably paid much more attention to the yellow objects.
Yet any blue objects were there the whole time.
They had not disappeared. You simply were not looking for them.
It is a practical demonstration of how selective attention can be, not proof that we see only what we concentrate on.
Now think of a worry that keeps coming back to your mind.
What are you looking for, every time you think about it again?
How to stop ruminating? Change the questions
When you are already stuck in a worry, some questions can keep bringing you back to the problem.
“Why does it always happen to me?”
“Why can't I stop thinking about it?”
“Why do things have to go this way?”
It is not the word “why” that is wrong. There are situations in which understanding the causes is essential.
The point is to recognize when a question is helping you understand and when, instead, it keeps bringing you back to the same thought.
So you can try changing the question.
“What do I really know about this situation?”
“What can I act on?”
“What possibilities am I not considering?”
“What is the next useful step?”
“What” and “how” questions, when directed toward concrete possibilities, can help you shift the focus from the problem to the resources available.
In my approach I start from this principle: where you direct your focus, you can also influence your mood.
And a different state can allow you to face the same situation with different resources and behaviors.
In my method, learning to direct your state through focus follows a precise sequence.
- You become aware. You recognize what you are concentrating your attention on and what state you are experiencing.
- You interrupt the automatic pattern. You notice that you keep going back to the same thoughts without getting any new information.
- You choose a direction. You identify what you want to concentrate your attention on and what result you want to achieve.
- You activate it. Through questions, representations and behaviors you begin to orient yourself toward the state you want.
- You amplify it. You recognize what helps you maintain that state and you strengthen the experience of it.
- You act. You turn the new direction into concrete behavior, checking the results.
In difficult moments you can ask yourself: “Does this state help me or limit me?”, “What state do I need, right now?”, “What resources do I have available?”.
In the evening you can use different questions: “What was the best moment of my day?”, “What did I learn today?”, “What can I improve for tomorrow?”.
Questions do not automatically change the situation. But they can change what you observe, the possibilities you consider and the way you choose to act.
An example: the short email
You get an email from your manager:
“Tomorrow I'd like to talk to you about the project.”
That's all.
Yet, as you head home, you think back to a mistake you made the week before.
“Maybe they noticed.”
Then you remember that during the last meeting they seemed colder than usual.
“They are probably angry.”
During the evening the thoughts keep piling up. A sentence of a few words has become the starting point of an entire conversation that, in reality, has not yet taken place.
Let's stop here.
What do you really know?
You know that your manager wants to talk to you about the project.
The rest?
It could be true. Or not.
You have one fact and several interpretations. But in the meantime you are reacting emotionally to a scenario you built without having verified it yet.
Now try changing the questions.
“What am I focusing on?”
“What does this email really say?”
“What other reasons might they have for wanting to talk to me?”
“What resources do I have to face the meeting?”
“What can I do to arrive prepared?”
You are not trying to convince yourself that everything will be fine.
You are widening the possibilities you are considering.
The email has stayed exactly the same.
So has tomorrow's meeting.
What can change is the state from which you prepare to face it.
You can spend the evening looking for confirmation of something you fear, or use the information available to decide how to prepare.
The fact has not changed. The questions have.
And with the questions, the possibilities you are able to see.
Which mistakes should you avoid?
- Continuing to ask yourself “why” when the question adds no new information. Understanding a cause can be useful; repeating the same question without moving forward can feed rumination.
- Waiting for the external situation to change before you can change the way you face it. You do not always have control over events, but you can explore different perspectives and behaviors.
- Confusing what you concentrate on with everything that exists. Attention selects. And what stays outside your focus might contain important information.
Think of a recent situation in which a message, a sentence or an episode stayed with you for hours.
What did you really know?
What had you added yourself?
And above all: if you changed the question you keep asking yourself, what possibility could you finally start to consider?
Choose that possibility and identify a concrete action to test it.
The full topic is on the page Mental Focus.
The complete method
Focus, internal state and the questions that direct them are developed in the Strategic NLP – The Invisible Blade series. The Premium Edition brings Volume I and Volume II together in a single path.
Discover the Premium Edition