Skip to content

How to respond to criticism?

Answered by Giovanni Ceroni, engineer and NLP coach in Cesena, Italy, author of Strategic NLP – The Invisible Blade. The topic continues in the Premium Edition: Volume I, “Effective Communication”, section “Feedback Sandwich”.

How to deal with criticism without feeling attacked? First of all, I would distinguish between criticism of the person and an observation about their behaviour. Because a mistake can call into question what you did, without calling into question your worth. In my approach I start from three checks: the intention you attribute to the speaker, the usefulness of the information received, and the distinction between behaviour and identity. It is from here that criticism can become an opportunity to improve.

Why does criticism hit us so hard?

Someone points out a mistake to you and, before you have even understood what they are telling you, you feel the need to defend yourself.

You explain, you justify, sometimes you counter-attack.

Perhaps you are not hearing only a remark about what you did. You may have taken it as a judgement about who you are.

And yet, there is an important difference between the two.

The person's worth is not in question. It is the behaviour that can be observed, evaluated and changed.

“You made a mistake” describes something that happened.

“You are incapable” turns that episode into a judgement about the person.

The fact may be the same. The meaning we attribute to it changes completely.

And when we learn to tell the two levels apart, we can begin to use the information we receive without automatically turning it into a threat to our identity.

Feedback versus failure

One of the NLP presuppositions offers a different perspective: there is no failure, only feedback.

It does not mean denying mistakes or pretending that every result is positive.

It means treating even an unwanted result as information we can learn something from.

A mistake tells us that a given strategy, in those conditions, did not produce the expected result.

The question becomes: what can I learn and what can I do differently?

A criticism can therefore point us to room for improvement.

We are not obliged to agree with every remark we receive, nor to accept every judgement.

But we can check whether it contains useful information.

The mistake concerns what happened. Room for improvement concerns what we can do from that moment on.

Three checks before you answer

  1. Intention. “With what intention is this person telling me this?” Do they want to help me improve, express a disagreement or simply release a tension? I cannot know their intention for certain, but I can observe how they communicate and, if necessary, ask for clarification. Telling apart what I know from what I am interpreting lets me choose better how to respond.
  2. Usefulness. “Is there something in what they are telling me that I can use?” Even a badly expressed remark can contain valuable information. I may not agree with the tone or the judgement and, at the same time, recognise an element that is useful for improving.
  3. Identity. “Are they questioning what I did or who I am?” If the criticism concerns the person, I can bring the conversation back to behaviour: “What, exactly, did not work?” Personal worth remains distinct from the appropriateness of a single action.

How to respond to criticism, in practice

And when you are the one giving criticism?

The same distinctions apply when we are the ones who have to give feedback.

In my book I propose the feedback sandwich, a communication strategy that starts from two fundamental points of attention: asking permission and keeping congruence between words, tone, behaviour and emotional state.

“Can I give you some feedback on the presentation?”

A simple question, which can encourage listening.

Then the feedback develops through three steps: what went well, what can be improved and how to improve it.

Imagine you have to talk to a team member after a presentation.

You could tell them: “You can't handle the audience's questions.”

Or: “You presented the content clearly. I noticed that, when you are interrupted, you tend to speed up your answers. You could leave a few seconds' pause before answering, so as to keep the rhythm and give room to the questions.”

In the first case you express a judgement about the person.

In the second you recognise what works, identify a behaviour that can be improved and propose a concrete possibility.

The value of feedback does not depend only on what you say, but also on what you allow the other person to understand and do.

Don't just point out a mistake. Offer information, tools and direction.

There is a distinction I consider fundamental: feedback is not there to establish how much a person is worth. It is there to make visible what works, what can be improved and the possibilities of acting differently.

Because what you cannot see, you can hardly choose to change.

I explore the topic further on the page The feedback sandwich.

The complete method

Communication, feedback and the difference between behaviour and identity are developed throughout The Invisible Blade. The Premium Edition brings Volume I and Volume II together in a single path.

Discover the Premium Edition