How to overcome impostor syndrome?
Answered by Giovanni Ceroni, engineer and NLP coach in Cesena, Italy, author of Strategic NLP – The Invisible Blade. The topic continues in the Premium Edition: Volume I, “Our Brain”, section “Impostor Syndrome”.
Impostor syndrome does not necessarily mean a lack of ability or skills. The way I interpret it, it is often the result of a process through which the mind tries to protect identity from a possible mistake. To deal with it, then, the question changes: instead of continually looking for new proof of your own worth, we can observe how a situation comes to be perceived as a threat to what we believe we are.
What is impostor syndrome?
It is an experience of inadequacy and illegitimacy that can persist even in the presence of concrete results and recognised competence. The person may attribute their successes to luck, to circumstances or to a misjudgment by others, fearing that they don't truly deserve the role they hold.
It is often summed up in one inner question: “Who am I to do this?”
In my model, what deserves attention is not only the assessment of your own abilities, but the risk the person associates with the possibility of making a mistake. A professional error can become, in their representation, a possible failure of reputation and identity.
The question is no longer only about what you can do. It comes to involve what you think you have the right to do.
Why do you feel like an impostor even when you have results?
In the model I propose, several cognitive processes can contribute to building or maintaining this perception. They don't necessarily all act, nor in the same way.
- Negativity bias: we tend to give more weight to one negative signal than to many positive elements.
- Loss aversion: the possibility of losing reputation or recognition can weigh more than the opportunity to achieve a new result.
- Social comparison: we compare what we know of our own uncertainties with the outer image that others show of themselves.
- Confirmation bias: when we think “I'm not good enough”, we risk selecting mostly the episodes that seem to confirm it.
- Spotlight effect: we may overestimate how much others observe, remember and judge our mistakes.
- Dunning-Kruger effect: it concerns distortions in the assessment of our own skills. It does not explain impostor syndrome on its own, but it points to the importance of distinguishing actual competence from the perception we have of it.
- Risk assessment: we may focus more on the reputational consequences of a mistake than on the abilities we have already shown.
- Role and status pressure: when responsibility, visibility and expectations increase, the fear of not being up to it can intensify too.
- Overthinking: going over the same episodes again and again can keep the perception of threat alive, even when the situation is over.
These processes are not, on their own, a measure of competence. They can, however, influence the way we interpret results, expectations and risks.
This is where, in my approach, it becomes interesting to observe not only what happened, but what meaning we have attributed to it.
How to deal with impostor syndrome? Six questions
When the thought “I'm not good enough” appears, we can explore it through six questions. They are not meant to convince you that you are competent. They are meant to widen the perspective from which you are looking at the situation.
- “What am I trying to protect right now?” Perhaps the recognition you have received, your professional reputation or the image you want to maintain. Recognising what you fear losing can help you distinguish the fact from the threat you are attributing to it.
- “If I saw myself from the outside while I think I'm not up to it, what would I notice about myself?” Observing the situation from an outside perspective can help you distinguish what you are experiencing from the conclusions you are drawing.
- “Am I questioning myself or the role?” You can still have something to learn while carrying out a role, without this becoming an overall judgment on you.
- “If I already had the recognition I'm looking for, would I still think this way?” Sometimes the perception of illegitimacy is also linked to the distance between the skills you have and the recognition you feel you have received.
- “Is this feeling improving my action or slowing it down?” Not all unpleasant feelings are useless. A certain caution can support preparation. But when you keep putting things off despite having the skills and the necessary conditions, it is worth observing what result you are getting.
- “Is this a choice or a reaction?” Are you deciding how to act based on what you know about the situation, or are you automatically following the fear of making a mistake?
The six questions open a possibility: moving from “I'm not good enough” to “What is happening, exactly, and what alternatives do I have?”
You don't need to erase a feeling in order to choose a different behaviour.
Which mistakes should you avoid?
- Constantly looking for new skills or new results to prove to yourself that you are up to it, without checking whether the difficulty is really about insufficient preparation.
- Confusing identity and role: turning a mistake during a presentation, a professional decision or a new activity into a general conclusion about your own worth.
- Leaving the judgment on your own legitimacy entirely to external recognition, without considering your actual skills and the results you have already achieved.
A concrete example
Imagine running a course for the first time in front of a large audience. You have prepared the material, you know the subject and you answer almost every question well.
On one, though, you don't know the answer straight away.
At the end of the course you don't think back to the two hours of work that went well. You keep going back to that question.
“There it is. I'm not prepared enough to do this yet.”
What does that episode really prove?
That you didn't know an answer?
Or that you don't have the competence, the legitimacy or the right to play that role?
The first answer describes a specific fact. The second turns that fact into a general judgment about the person.
And what if not knowing an answer were simply information about what you can still learn?
The fact stays the same. What you can do with it changes.
When is it advisable to see a professional?
A moment of insecurity in front of a new responsibility is not necessarily the same as a persistent difficulty.
When, instead, the sense of inadequacy causes significant suffering, limits your choices or compromises your well-being and daily life, it is advisable to turn to a psychologist or a doctor for an appropriate assessment.
The questions proposed on this page are tools for reflection. They do not replace a psychological assessment or any clinical treatment.
I go into this distinction on the page NLP, coaching and psychotherapy: what is the difference?.
A role can change, a skill can be developed and a behaviour can be improved. A person's worth should not be called into question every time something doesn't go as planned.
If you want to explore the relationship between beliefs, identity, role and the perception of risk, you will find the full topic, with the trainer example and the six questions, on the page Impostor Syndrome.
The complete method
Impostor syndrome is analysed in Volume I of The Invisible Blade, as an example of how several cognitive biases work together in a single behaviour. The Premium Edition brings Volume I and Volume II together in a single path.
Discover the Premium Edition